Zim Education Sec slams ZANU-PF use of schools for primaries

Zimbabwe Election

By Zimbabwe Election Reporter

26 June 2013

HARARE – The Education Minister in Zimbabwe’s shaky coalition government, Senator David Coltart, has slammed the use of schools by President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF party to conduct its primary elections.

In a statement sent to Nehanda Radio, Coltart said “I have stated, as policy, on numerous occasions in the last 4 years that schools should not be used under any circumstances for partisan political activity.

“I have stated the various sound educational reasons for that policy which include the fact that children and teachers need a safe and peaceful environment to study in. This is a policy which has been in place for many years, at least in theory, and which I have simply reinforced.”

Initially Zanu PF had claimed its elections would be held within one day (Tuesday) but this spilled over into Wednesday because of violence, confusion, ballot paper shortages and boycotts by disgruntled candidates and supporters. There were also several arrests as rival camps clashed in physical battles.

But the disruption in classes for children has annoyed Coltart who said “It goes without saying that the use of schools has been done without my permission and in flagrant breach of that policy. I have no doubt that the education of the children in the schools used will have been adversely affected.”

Coltart said none of the other major parties have had to use schools to conduct their primary elections and had not disrupted the lives and education of children. He said “some within Zanu PF will have done this as a deliberate snub to remind the public who is physically more powerful in this Government.

“I am of course powerless to prevent this conduct because there is no point in turning to the Police or other law enforcement agencies who have for some time demonstrated their own partisanship. Likewise school heads cannot be criticised because they are at the mercy of local Zanu PF operatives who would make their lives miserable if they so much as tried to resist and protect the policy.

“However those who feel smug about what they have done today should think about their legacy and the adverse consequences of their actions on the lives of the children affected. It goes without saying that I condemn in the strongest terms possible the use of schools for partisan political purposes,” Coltart said.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Coltart slams Zanu PF use of schools for primary elections

Nehanda Radio

By Lance Guma

26 June 2013

HARARE – The Education Minister in Zimbabwe’s shaky coalition government, Senator David Coltart, has slammed the use of schools by President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF party to conduct its primary elections.

In a statement sent to Nehanda Radio, Coltart said “I have stated, as policy, on numerous occasions in the last 4 years that schools should not be used under any circumstances for partisan political activity.

“I have stated the various sound educational reasons for that policy which include the fact that children and teachers need a safe and peaceful environment to study in. This is a policy which has been in place for many years, at least in theory, and which I have simply reinforced.”

Initially Zanu PF had claimed its elections would be held within one day (Tuesday) but this spilled over into Wednesday because of violence, confusion, ballot paper shortages and boycotts by disgruntled candidates and supporters. There were also several arrests as rival camps clashed in physical battles.

But the disruption in classes for children has annoyed Coltart who said “It goes without saying that the use of schools has been done without my permission and in flagrant breach of that policy. I have no doubt that the education of the children in the schools used will have been adversely affected.”

Coltart said none of the other major parties have had to use schools to conduct their primary elections and had not disrupted the lives and education of children. He said “some within Zanu PF will have done this as a deliberate snub to remind the public who is physically more powerful in this Government.

“I am of course powerless to prevent this conduct because there is no point in turning to the Police or other law enforcement agencies who have for some time demonstrated their own partisanship. Likewise school heads cannot be criticised because they are at the mercy of local Zanu PF operatives who would make their lives miserable if they so much as tried to resist and protect the policy.

“However those who feel smug about what they have done today should think about their legacy and the adverse consequences of their actions on the lives of the children affected. It goes without saying that I condemn in the strongest terms possible the use of schools for partisan political purposes,” Coltart said.

 

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

The Online rallies

The Herald

By Knowledge Mushohwe

26 June 2013

A FEW years ago, the only way a politician could interact directly with potential voters during an election campaign was through mass gatherings.

Rallies are probably the single biggest instrument for political information dissemination.

The principal purpose of a rally is to gather as many people as possible to show support and solidarity for an issue, individual or cause.

Such a gathering may have an extended objective.

A large turnout may generate publicity through the mass media and the key ideas may filter through to a wider audience.
Rallies also educate both the electorate and the prospective leaders as well as stimulate further action.

They may raise money, energise and inspire both leaders and supporters, serve notice on the opposition, and help build alliances.

Compared to other forms of campaigning and with the exception of mass violence, rallies involve very little risk, they have high visibility, and are often punctuated with fun, including singing, eating drama, poetry and mock demonstrations. There are however, several challenges associated with holding of political rallies.

They are extremely weather sensitive.

Bad weather, such as windy conditions, heavy rains or very low temperatures can significantly lower the overall turnout.  Because numbers in campaigning are everything, a poor turnout can be disastrous politically.

Low turnout may be seen as lack of general support and this may encourage opponents.

Crucially, rallies are usually long, especially when the star speaker thinks he/she is entitled to arrive late.

When rallies have too many speakers and not enough music, the speakers frequently say nothing new or interesting, and the whole event may be largely passive and may evoke to neutrals a party-image atmosphere that is difficult to enthuse them.

One type of rally that is cost effective and appears to be gaining popularity is mass communication through digital means.

Social networking forums such as Facebook, Blogging and Twitter are bringing politicians closer to the public.  Because the public is always online looking for information relevant to their social and political life facets, politicians need little marketing to connect to the right crowd.

Minister of Tourism and Hospitality Industry Walter Mzembi for example has almost 5 000 Facebook followers while Information Technology minister Nelson Chamisa has over 3 000 friends.

According to media personnel that constant communicate with politicians in one way or the other,  leaders making use of social networking forums are not many.

MDC-T’s Douglas Mwonzora, Theresa Makone, Thokozani Khupe, Chamisa, Jessie Majome and MDC’s David Coltart are frequent users of either Facebook, Twitter or both. In the other MDC formation, the feuding leaders, Arthur Mutambara and Welshman Ncube are familiar names on Facebook.

For Zanu-PF only MP Anastansia Ndlovu and ministers Mzembi and Saviour Kasukuwere appear very keen to communicate with the general public through social networking.

It is rather unfortunate that very few political leaders recognise the value of the internet in information dissemination. The majority of information non political leaders available on the internet is secondary data sourced by a third party and repackaged for the general public’s consumption.

Primary data, raw and unedited from the leaders themselves would prove invaluable in the relationship between them and the electorate.

There is no chance of misquotation by middlemen, and with no editing the information would be as direct and as accurate as possible.

Zanu-PF may complain through the media about sanctions but it would have been more effective if the leaders set up their own social networking accounts to explain, in their own words, point by point, the negative effects of these illegal measures on the general public.

The popularity of a pseudonym Facebook account called “Baba Jukwa” with 183 000 likes, shows the political data vacuum that exists is only being partially filled by a few individuals.

The online consumers are obviously there and waiting and with file sharing and mass communication between ‘friends’ a routine for most, advertising a new source of information is not the most difficult task.

A politician with several thousand followers can instigate an “online rally” by providing direct information to his/her followers.

Online rallies have a big advantage over the conventional rallies in that both the public and the leaders as individuals have a better way of asking questions, giving answers and view what others have to say about relevant information. Conventional forms of rallies require a lot of work for them to succeed.

Initial meetings, involving many people, have to develop a structure for overall co-ordination, and accessibility and availability of the venue are primary concerns at the start. The timetable, printing of rally accessories, advertising, endorsements, transport logistics, fund-raising and co-operation with the media are rally-related issues that require brainstorming and proper planning. But online rallies require very little.

Social networking provides a cost-effective political dialogue involving up to several thousand people.

Unlike the conventional means, online political rallies form a complex communication model where information flows both ways between politicians and the general public, between one member of the public and another, and this may bring in more and more participants linked to the initial communicators.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Zanu (PF) primaries disrupt schooling

The Zimbabwean

By Nelson Sibanda

25 June 2013

Minister of Education, Sport, Arts and Culture, David Coltart, has expressed concern over the disruption of activities at schools due to the ongoing Zanu (PF) primary elections.

Some of the primaries are being held at schools across the country in breach of a government policy position that prohibits partisan political programmes at schools.

Coltart said it was unfortunate that there were some people in Zanu (PF) who disregarded the educational interests of children.

“A day lost in educational needs of a child will not be recovered and would cost the future of the child,” Coltart told The Zimbabwean in a telephone interview.

He said the education policy on politics at educational institutions was very clear and there was no need for any party to hold political activities at schools.

MDC-T issued a statement reflecting its dismay at the loss of school lessons by innocent children at the hands of Zanu (PF).

“MDC totally deplores Zanu (PF) holding its primary elections at schools country-wide. The move is not only insensitive but a complete violation of the children’s rights to education as the exercise would cause serious disruption on the learning time of children,” reads part of the statement.

The party added: “Given the loss of learning time that the Zanu (PF)’s chaotic exercise is going to cause to the innocent children, it clearly demonstrates the unflinching subterfuge of Zanu (PF) to malign and disregard the millions of already disadvantaged pupils in schools.”

MDC-T called on the ministry of education to ensure that students’ basic rights were not violated in pursuit of political space.

In Nyanga, the primaries are being held at schools such as Chapataranga (Ward 6), Zachiwo (Ward 5), Mazarura Primary (wWrd 7), Manjanja Primary, Kazozo (Ward 3), Tsengerai Primary (Ward 4) and Nyautare (Ward 8).

Other schools affected in the area are Fombe Secondary (Ward 1), Chifambe (ward 2), Kambudzi Primary (Ward 9), Chipindo (Ward 11), Bumhira (Ward 12) and Sakurira in Ward 13.

In Marondera East, Chief Svosve area, the primaries have affected school activities at Bopoma Primary, Dimbiti Primary, St. Ludger Primary, Masikana, Dhirihori Primary and Secondary, Mupazvirihwo and St. Martins Primary Schools.

Zanu (PF)’s Secretary for Information and Publicity, Rugare Gumbo, was unreachable.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Mobile Voter Registration Centres for Week 25th-30th June 2013

Please find below a list of all the Mobile Voter Registration Centres that are operating this week in Bulawayo.

 

Ward                                        Venue                                                                          Date

3                              i)              KhumaloPrimary School                                  23/06/13-27/06/13

ii)             Centenary Primary School                               28/06/13-01/07/13

6                              i)             Founders High School                                        22/06/13-25/06/13

7                              i)              LotshePrimary School                                       26/06/13-29/06/13

18                           i)              Magwegwe Community Hall                            24/06/13-27/06/13

20                           i)              MgoqoPrimary School                                      28/06/13-01/07/13

12                           i)              LobengulaSecondary School                           22/06/13-25/06/13

13                           i)              Iminyela Community Hall                                  26/06/13-30/06/13

26                           i)              SenzangakhonaPrimary School                      22/06/13-26/06/13

27                           i)              Pumula South Community Hall                       27/06/13-30/06/13

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Statement regarding using schools to conduct primary elections

Statement by the Minister of Education, Sport, Arts and Culture regarding using schools to conduct primary elections

I have received several reports and complaints today about schools being used countrywide to conduct ZANU PF primary elections. I have stated, as policy, on numerous occasions in the last 4 years that schools should not be used under any circumstances for partisan political activity. I have stated the various sound educational reasons for that policy which include the fact that children and teachers need a safe and peaceful environment to study in.

This is a policy which has been in place for many years, at least in theory, and which I have simply reinforced.

It goes without saying that the use of schools has been done without my permission and in flagrant breach of that policy. I have no doubt that the education of the children in the schools used will have been adversely affected. None of the other major parties have had to use schools to conduct their primary elections and have been able to hold their primaries without disrupting the lives and education of children. So there is no excuse for this type of conduct.

I have no doubt that some within Zanu PF will have done this as a deliberate snub to remind the public who is physically more powerful in this Government. I am of course powerless to prevent this conduct because there is no point in turning to the Police or other law enforcement agencies who have for sometime demonstrated their own partisanship. Likewise school heads cannot be criticised because they are at the mercy of local Zanu PF operatives who would make their lives miserable if they so much as tried to resist and protect the policy. However those who feel smug about what they have done today should think about their legacy and the adverse consequences of their actions on the lives of the children affected.

It goes without saying that I condemn in the strongest terms possible the use of schools for partisan political purposes. I long for the day when our education system and educational institutions become sacrosanct. That clearly will never happen under a Zanu PF government.

Senator David Coltart.
Minister of education, Sport, Arts and Culture.
Harare.

25th June 2013

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Education Ministry in a quandary Paltry $20 000 allocated for two months

Sunday News

By Vusumuzi Dube 

23 June 2013

THE Ministry of Education, Sport, Arts and Culture is in a quandary after the Government recently allocated it a paltry $20 000 meant to cover administration   costs for the months of May and June, a situation that has been described as traumatic for the education sector. Education, Sport, Arts and Culture Minister Senator David Coltart revealed that his

ministry was facing crisis because the $20 000 was far from being enough for them to operate for the two months.

He revealed that in such a scenario their provincial offices risked being evicted because of failure to pay rentals.

“While the Minister of Finance Tendai Biti has so far assured us that he will give us a further $300 000 that is after I put some pressure on him, I must say that we had been allocated a paltry $20 000 and all things being equal this falls far short of what we need to cover all our costs even just for a month.

“To be frank, our provincial offices will risk closure as we won’t be able to pay our rentals with such an amount and that in itself will spell great danger to the education sector as a whole because without our provincial offices, our operations will be crippled,” said Minister Coltart.

The minister noted that they especially required money to purchase fuel as this was a key resource for their teacher-monitoring activities.

“As you might know, we really need money for us to effectively monitor the performance of our teachers, therefore, with such an amount we can’t buy fuel for our provincial and district officers and overally this is very traumatic to the education sector because basically we need as much financial resources as possible if we are really going to invest in the education sector,” he said.

Senator Coltart said all in all the ministry needed just over $300 000 for them to operate in a month.

Minister Coltart has in the past expressed concern with regards to the Government’s budget allocation to the education sector saying this was not adequate for the full revival of the sector.

According to the 2013 National Budget, the Ministry of Finance allocated $754 million to the Education Ministry.

Results from this year’s O-level examinations exposed the need for the Government to channel most of its financial resources to the sector as out of the 172 689 candidates whor egistered for public examinations last year, only 31 767 managed passes in at least five subjects or more.

The O-level pass rate stood at 18,4 percent, a 1,1 percent drop from the 2011 statistics.

Previously, the pass rate had been as follows: 2003 (13 percent); 2004 (10,2 percent); 2005 (12 percent); 2006 (14,2 percent); 2007 (9,85 percent); 2008 (14,44 percent); 2009 (19,33 percent) and 2010 (16,5 percent).

The A-level pass rate for 2012 also marginally dropped to 82,09 percent from 85,2 percent the previous year.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Police ban PTUZ demo against Coltart

Daily News
By Mugove Tafirenyika
23 June 2013
HARARE - Police have barred Progressive Teachers’ Union of Zimbabwe (PTUZ) from staging a demonstration against Education minister David Coltart.

The teachers union wanted to present a damning petition to Coltart protesting arbitrary transfer of its members from Harare metropolitan province.

Raymond Majongwe, PTUZ secretary general said police had refused to sanction the march to Coltart’s office notwithstanding the fact that the minister and his permanent secretary Constance Chigwamba — who had been formally informed in writing about the planned march —  had not objected to the demonstration.

Paul Nyathi, police spokesperson, said PTUZ’s application had a lot of inadequacies in terms of the provisions of the law hence its dismissal.

“The notification was not in conformity with the provisions of the law because they did not indicate the route they were going to take and the number of participants in the intended march,” Nyathi said.

“Moreover they gave us very short notice and so we called their representative and explained this.”

But Majongwe said his organisation had notified the police in writing in a June 12, 2013 letter in terms of the requirements of the Public Order and Security Act [Chapter 11:17]. 

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

City lawyers eye MDC tickets

Southern Eye

By Nqobani Ndlovu

21 June 2013

TWO prominent Bulawayo lawyers have forwarded their names for nomination as MDC candidates for the party’s primaries expected to be concluded at the weekend.

Sindiso Mazibisa of Cheda and Partners and Matshobana Ncube of Phulu and Ncube are set to slug it out with other prospective candidates in primary elections for the Welshman Ncube-led MDC, amid indications that the consensus method had failed in their coveted constituencies.

Mazibisa has expressed interest in the Magwegwe constituency, where he will face off with Oscar Dube.

Ncube on the other hand will do battle with Ngwalo Nyathi and a candidate only referred to as Dube.

MDC spokesman Nhlanhla Dube will on the other hand battle it out with Dingulwazi Masuku for the Lobengula-Njube constituency.

“If we get venues, the primaries will go ahead at the weekend. Everything is dependent on venues,” MDC provincial spokesman Edwin Ndlovu said.

Meanwhile, Education minister David Coltart — Bulawayo East Senator — has been spared the agony of going through primary elections after he was nominated unopposed.

Coltart is one of four party officials that did not go through the primary elections to be selected to represent the MDC in the upcoming elections.

Coltart has been confirmed together with Sibongile Maphosa, the MDC secretary for the women’s assembly (Bulawayo Central) while Thabile Ndlovu, a district chairperson in Makokoba and councillor Israel Mabaleka, were selected to represent Makokoaba and Luveve constituencies respectively.

The MDC is using a consensus process in its candidate selection system where aspiring legislators meet to discuss among themselves and agree on who will represent the party in the elections.

Where candidates fail to agree on who will represent a constituency, primaries are held.

Primary elections have so far been held in five constituencies.

Duduzile Dube, a national executive member, won primary elections to represent the MDC in Mpopoma-Pelandaba, while Loyisa Ncube a district executive member won in Pumula, Christabel Sibanda, an executive member in the women’s assembly (Emakhandeni-Entumbane), Pastor Esnart Bulayani an organiser in the women’s assembly (Bulawayo South) and
Alderman Charles Mpofu won primaries to represent the party in Nketa.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment

Presidential decrees — Mugabe’s lethal weapon

The Independent

By Brian Chitemba

21 June 2013

PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe seems to have perfected the art of abusing the draconian Presidential Powers (Temporary Measures) Act (PPTM Act) to make far-reaching changes to electoral laws to suit his political agenda before every election, analysts say.

According to Section 2(1)(c) of the Act, the president shall only issue a decree if “because of the urgency, it is inexpedient to await the passage through parliament of an Act dealing with the situation”.

However, Mugabe, before every election, particularly since 2000, has always resorted to the emergency powers to change the rules of the game.

Despite attempts in the new constitution to restrict the use of the powers of decree, Mugabe last week unilaterally amended the Electoral Act through an extraordinary Government Gazette Statutory Instrument 85 of 2013 to pave way for the proclamation of elections dates and self-serving changes to the law. He has always done this before every election.

Before the 2008 elections, Mugabe enacted Statutory Instrument Number 46 of 2008 in a move which his rival, MDC-T leader Morgan Tsvangirai said showed “everything that is wrong with this election in particular and Zimbabwe in general”.

The regulations sought to amend Sections 55, 59 and 60 of the Electoral Act Chapter 2:13 as amended by the Electoral Laws Act Amendment No 17 of 2007. Amendment No 17 to the Electoral Act, which became law on January 11 2008, was a piece of law negotiated between the MDC parties and Zanu PF during the Sadc-sponsored talks facilitated by former South African president Thabo Mbeki.

That piece of legislation was agreed to and signed by the parties in Pretoria on October 30 2007 and presented to Sadc through Mbeki on the very same day. Those amendments, together with changes to the Public Order and Security Act, Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act and the Broadcasting Act, which were all passed in parliament on December 20 2007 and gazetted on January 11 2008, were hotly contested.

“Mugabe’s appetite of making presidential decrees through his legendary abuse of the Presidential Powers (Temporary Measures) Act Chapter 10:20 is unacceptable as it is a clear breach of the rule of law,” MDC-T secretary-general Tendai Biti said at the time.

“Allowing Mugabe to make decrees is a breach of the doctrine of the separation of powers. Put simply, the Presidential Powers (Temporary Measures) Act is itself clearly unconstitutional.”

The PPTM Act came into force in 1987 when Mugabe became executive president after the abolition of the ceremonial presidency and prime ministerial posts. The architect of legislation was the late Justice minister Eddison Zvobgo.

Since then, Mugabe has been abusing the PPTM Act to make changes before elections to ensure his re-election.

After realising that Zanu PF’s urban support base was waning, Mugabe invoked the PPTM Act in 1995.

Prior to the 2002 presidential elections, he was at it again as he used his presidential powers to introduce a raft of amendments to the Electoral Act which influenced the running and outcome of the polls.

Barely 24 hours before the polls, Mugabe invoked the PPMT Act to make a cocktail of changes to Section 158 of the Electoral Act resulting in the disenfranchement of “aliens”, banning of postal votes, limiting the number of polling stations in urban centres and extending the voter registration campaign in Zanu PF strongholds.

The MDC-T challenged Mugabe’s controversial actions in the Supreme Court, but the case was thrown out a month after the elections.

In similar fashion last week, Mugabe used his powers to amend the Electoral Act and smuggled in a provision which extends the voter registration exercise by 12 days after nomination day.

Section 26A of the Electoral Act 2:13 initially provided that voter registration be finalised 24 hours before the nomination court sits after which 44 days must elapse between the proclamation of election dates and polling day.

Mugabe abused his contentious powers to meet the July 31 election deadline as ordered by the Constitutional Court (Concourt).

MDC secretary for legal affairs David Coltart, who is a lawyer, criticised Mugabe for using the presidential powers last week describing his move as “unconstitutional” since Section 157(1) states that only an Act of parliament can be used.

He argued Section 2(1)(c) of the PPTM Act provides that the president shall only issue a decree in urgent cases which cannot await parliamentary debate, but last week’s proclamation was not necessary as parliament is still sitting until June 29.

If changes to the Electoral Amendment Bill were urgent, parliament could have convened immediately to pass the amendments agreed to at last week’s cabinet meeting.

“Section 157(1) of the new constitution states that ‘An Act of parliament must provide for the conduct of elections’. In other words, the new constitution specifically requires that the matter of electoral process be provided for by an Act. In other words, the Presidential Powers Act, as undemocratic as it is, cannot be used for this type of matter even if it is deemed urgent,” Coltart said.

“The flip side of the same coin is that Section 157(1) states that an Act of parliament must provide for the conduct of elections. Section 2(1) makes it quite clear that the president can only issue ‘regulations’. Regulations are not an Act of parliament.”

However, constitutional lawyer Lovemore Madhuku defended Mugabe’s use of presidential powers saying he by-passed parliament to comply with the Concourt ruling.

But Constitutional and Parliamentary Affairs minister Eric Matinenga insisted Mugabe acted “unconstitutionally”.

Sadc leaders resolved last weekend Mugabe’s amendments must be reversed and done through parliament.

Posted in Blog | Leave a comment